article url

New Labor Department data show hundreds of thousands of reported Biden jobs were fake

Wed May 14 2025
MXM Exclusive
40
244
19 Comments

Quick Hit:

A new release from the Labor Department has confirmed that hundreds of thousands of jobs claimed by the Biden administration never existed. The updated data reveals a stark discrepancy between previously reported job gains and the actual state of the U.S. labor market, raising serious questions about the credibility of Biden-era economic reporting and vindicating widespread skepticism among voters and economists.

Key Details:

  • The Bureau of Labor Statistics initially claimed the U.S. added nearly 400,000 jobs from July to September 2023. The new, more accurate data shows a net loss of 1,000 private-sector jobs for that period.

  • A recent annual benchmark revision from the BLS cut 598,000 jobs from the March 2023–March 2024 period.

  • Additional data suggests that instead of gaining nearly 800,000 jobs mid-2023, the U.S. economy actually shed over 160,000 private-sector jobs.

Diving Deeper:

The Labor Department's latest release undercuts one of the central narratives promoted by the Biden administration throughout his term—that job growth was robust and the economy was on a historic rebound. As families struggled with inflation, spiking interest rates, and record-breaking credit card debt, former President Biden and his media allies insisted that the economy was in the best shape it had ever been.

However, according to a recent analysis by economist E.J. Antoni, Ph.D., the government’s monthly job reports, which were widely touted as proof of Biden’s economic “success,” were deeply misleading. These reports are based on a limited survey of roughly 200,000 businesses. In contrast, the more comprehensive Business Employment Dynamics (BED) data—derived from a census of 12 million businesses—tells a very different story.

The BED data just released for Q3 2023 shows that the supposed addition of 399,000 jobs was pure fiction. In fact, there was a net loss of 1,000 private-sector jobs. And this isn’t an isolated discrepancy. Between March and June 2023, while monthly reports claimed a gain of 398,000 jobs, the BED data found a loss of 163,000 jobs. These aren’t small adjustments; they represent a fundamental contradiction in the federal government’s portrayal of the economy.

Making matters worse, the annual benchmark revisions released earlier this year retroactively erased 598,000 nonfarm payroll jobs from the books. This kind of downward revision—done quietly and without the media fanfare that accompanied the original job reports—suggests a troubling pattern of exaggeration or at least statistical manipulation during the Biden administration.

While the BLS acknowledges some variation between datasets due to methodology, the consistency and scale of these downward revisions under Biden's watch raise red flags. It also reinforces what many Americans already knew from experience: the economy was not working for them.

This revelation helps explain why voters delivered a decisive victory to President Donald Trump in the 2024 election, entrusting him with a mandate to restore economic stability. Trump’s win, capturing not only the electoral college but the popular vote—was in large part a rejection of what many saw as dishonesty and neglect by Biden-era officials.

(AP Photo/Susan Walsh)

Comments

...loading comments
Share your opinion - login or signup to comment.

Other Recent Articles